Why the Arena Bowl wasn’t Super
- Football -
![]()
ESPN has been shoving the Arena Football League down my throat all summer. This season was the first of a five year deal ESPN has with the AFL. Enjoying the success of NFL’s Monday Night Football, ESPN decided to broadcast football year round. With Mike and Mike commentating games ESPN was off and running with Arena Football. Last Sunday, July 29, 2007, was the leagues Arena Bowl. Powerhouse San Jose SaberCats faced off against Cinderella story Columbus Destroyers in their version of the Super Bowl. If any game could convince a die hard NFL fan that the Arena Football League was for real, this was it.
So here are the Pros and Cons of the AFL;
Pro;
The field is only 50 yards and is surrounded by a 4 foot wall so you can’t run out of bounds. The size of the field means high scoring games and relatively fast drives. I watched drives on average of 6 plays, 37 yards, touchdown. The out wall around the field is cool, because who wouldn’t love watching someone getting blasted into or over a wall?
Pro;
The game is 8 on 8, offensive primarily consists of 3 offensive linemen (one of which is a tight end who can catch passes) 3 receivers, quarterback and a running back. The Defense has 3 defensive linemen, 3 cornerbacks, and 2 linebackers.
Con;
Because an offense only has three offensive linemen running is unlikely. Imagine calling a toss where your tackle pulls to block even though he is lined up next to the center.
Pro;
Defensives have no safeties leaving cornerbacks on an island every snap. To make things interesting, one receiver is allowed a running start at the line of scrimmage. Picture Santana Moss or Steve Smith starting 10 or 15 yards behind the line of scrimmage having the advantage of being at top speed by the time the ball is hiked. To make matters worse, linebackers are not allowed to leave the box. So that means no zones, no double teams, just man on man coverage in a no run league on a 50 yard field.
This is why teams score 50, 60, 70 points a game and players like Matt Nagy can throw for 151 touchdowns during the 2005 season!
Con;
For a league with no safeties there weren’t enough deep balls for my liking. It was a lot of dink and dunk up the field which was disappointing. Fifty yards is not a long distance to travel when you know the defense has to go man every play. An offensive unit can run 3 or 4 flat routes or curls and is already within the 10 yard line. It may be high scoring but it’s also boring.
Con;
Because there are no Safeties there are no big hits. Who wants to watch that?
The Gregg Williams in me;
One thing that makes me curious is if my linebackers can’t leave the box, why not blitz every play? They can’t help in coverage so might as well do something. If you blitz both backers you have 5 players (3 d-lineman, 2-LBs) attacking 4 players (3 o-lineman, 1 RB). Wouldn’t that negate the disadvantage you suffer in the secondary? The offense could react by having the Tackle/Tight End leak out for a pass, but offensively you only have 4 players blocking 5, can you afford to only have 3 blocking 5? I doubt it.
Pro;
There is no punting and missed field goals are live balls, Devin Hester would flourish in this league. Speaking of kick returners, the NFL should steal some of the AFL kick-off specialist. The field is only 50 yards meaning by the time the returner receives the ball the defense is already on top of him. To still be able to run the ball back is amazing. Trestin George run back a 50 kickoff return in the Arena Bowl and when his speed was electronically tracked he ran the equivalent to a 4.2 forty! How productive could George be on a 100 yard field actually having some room to work?
Pro;
Fans are allowed to keep balls that go into the crowd.
Con;
At first I liked the idea of fans getting to keep balls that go into the crowd, unlike the NFL who will fine a player $2,500 if they throw a ball into the stands. But as I watched the game, this will eventually become problematic for the league. Fans sit directly behind the 4 foot wall. Whenever a play ends up near the wall, fans scream at the top of their lungs, reach over onto the field, and beg for the ball. I witnessed cornerbacks going for interceptions near the wall and have fans grab the ball as if the cornerback was Moises Alou playing for the Cubs. I watched fans lean half way over the wall to yell at players on the ground and even saw a group of kids celebrating so hard that one fell over the wall onto the field! Fans should not be that close to the action, if David Stern wasn’t so pre-occupied I would have him send a tape of the Auburn Palace melee to AFL commissioner David Baker.
Final verdict;
Honestly, it reminds me more of my flag football league than it does the NFL. I’ll watch it during the dog days of summer, but not during the NFL season or during the NBA season. The one really cool thing about the game is that the quarterbacks are mic’d up and get interviewed after almost ever scoring drive. This allows fans to get a window into the huddle and conversations between quarterbacks and coaches. During the game Columbus Destroyer’s quarterback Matt Nagy loses his mind in the second quarter. With his team down by two touchdowns Nagy starts panicking, yelling at coaches and dropping f-bombs, it was awesome. I wish the NFL would do this, think about how many Peyton Manning breakdowns we could have witnessed in the past. We would know what really went on in the Donovan McNabb/Terrell Owens huddles. All in all I guess the AFL Arena Bowl wasn’t that bad.
Bonds hit career number 754 Friday night, making it only a matter of time before he finally puts one out on the road, gets booed by everyone, including Bud Selig (quietly, under his breath anyway), and hates the world that much more. At least
Instead, humility and vulnerability made an unusual appearance as Stern uncomfortably attempted to put into words his feelings on the federal investigation into one of his highest-rated referees, Tim Donaghy, who is allegedly linked to a points-shaving scandal involving the mob.
Now, as indictments go, due process must take its course. Juries need to be set, trial dates need to be picked and all the jazz that comes along with public relations need to be ironed out. 

His riff with Scoop Jackson and hip hop music was nothing new, but in this interview he was very candid with both, as well as adding that his fellow coworker was “bojangling” — a word that makes people of all sorts, especially big networks, uncomfortable. He’s since taken to a higher platform, appearing on CNN and Oprah, accusing people across the country of bojangling. Also, let’s clear this one thing up — Whitlock is not “the voice” of Black America. Rather, he is “a voice” of Black America. His views are just one of millions but he seems to make the most noise by calling people out — rightfully or not — from his sports platform, either by way of his Kansas City Star post or AOL Sports.
Not a big fan of Whitlock, Etan Thomas is one of those athletes who isn’t afraid to speak out about his feelings of societal issues. More athletes should follow suit and take Etan as a shining example. He writes for SLAM magazine online, and at one point
Zirini knows how impactful Etan Thomas is — he
He’s disliked in circles both black and white for his unorthodox writing voice that is definitely his own, but he’s been around the writing game for many, many years, notably moving from a big-time spot at SLAM magazine notably before he moved over to ESPN.com. Say what you will about Scoop’s presentation or laid back, conversational style of writing, but he does have his own voice. Much of the debate surrounding him tends to be whether or not he is a “representative” of Black America, or if he’s being stereotypical by adding an atypical voice to a very popular network’s site. He’s unorthodox and although he may not be universally loved, he does his thing regardless of any dissenting opinions.
