The most wonderful time of year is here for sports. It’s called March Madness and it’s the sports world’s savior for disasters like steroids, spy-gate, the BCS, crooked refs, hockey, criminal activity, and more. March Madness is sports at its most pure and at its best. Those first four days of the tourney, that wonderfully long weekend of sunrise-to-sunset college basketball is a cure-all to the anti-climatic and scandal-ridden world of games that we have to endure month after month.
Before the tournament begins, though, the field must be set, meaning the brackets must be filled out. That is accomplished, as most of you know, by the NCAA Selection Committee. This group of 10 bear on their shoulders the task of seeding the 31 teams that earned automatic bids by winning their conference championships. They then, and most importantly, pick the remaining 34 “at-large teams” that will also be welcomed. That final product of 65 schools will be introduced at 7 pm this month on March 16th.
But there is one glaring problem with this whole process and it will surely, perhaps even this year, bite the NCAA right on its overly-confident hind-side. The bracket unveiling happens at 7 pm this year, as it does every year, on a Sunday night in mid-March. The problem is that with all of those career-changing selections being made, the NCAA has little time to compose itself since five conference championship games will be played earlier in the day on the 16th.
What does that mean? Well, if you’re one of the 15 teams or so that are on the tourney “bubble,” meaning you may get in, you may not, you now have the selection group juggling your fate based on what happens an hour prior to the show’s start. This rushed schedule does not help the NCAA at all and I fear it will ultimately lead to an embarrassing situation.
Now, I don’t know about you, but I’ve never taken 65 of anything and ranked them, paired them together for competitions, and then assigned them to cities they must travel to based on geographic location, but I assume it’s pretty hard. It’s so hard, in fact, it would seem a group of 10 different deciding individuals may need up to a day to finalize such an important happening. Not the NCAA. With the show airing at 7 pm sharp, the selectors have the Big 12 conference championship starting at 3 pm (ending presumptively at 5) and the Big 10 conference title starting at 3:30 pm (ending at what they pray is 5:30). Now, if any bubble teams are involved and, in a worst case scenario, win those matches, the tourney committee then has to juggle the future of up to 15 school programs in about a half-hour span. Why do they put this pressure on themselves? Here’s what could happen…
Embarrassing scenario #1: According to ESPN’s Bubble Watch website, the Big 12 has only two locks, or tournament-guaranteed teams, which are Texas and Kansas. They also, have six bubble teams, or teams that could presumptively make it by selection. Now, let’s say for example that neither Texas nor Kansas make it to the conference championship on the 16th. It’s 3 pm, and tipping off at center court are Texas Tech and Oklahoma State. Both are decent teams despite their lackluster 15-13 regular-season records.
Now, one of those teams has to win and it won’t be until 5 pm, two hours before the committee’s final selections are aired. Let’s say the game is neck-and-neck and OK State wins on a buzzer beater. How many Big 12 teams does the committee let in? State is a lock because they won the title. Texas and Kansas are also locks. Now, what about the five other bubble teams that also have a chance? Who is let in and who is left out? Baylor and A&M had stronger records, but it was Texas Tech that lost on a lucky buzzer-beating shot. More importantly, what about the mid-major teams around the country like Creighton, Davidson, and VCU that are also competing for those spots?
Judgment is rushed in this scenario, and that’s not good for the NCAA or the game of basketball.
Embarrassing Scenario #2: Let’s say the Big 10 tourney title comes down to Wisconsin and Iowa. Now, Wisconsin is the #10 overall team in the nation and therefore a sure lock on a Big Dance future. But Iowa is not supposed to be in this situation. They were never supposed to get this far. And now it’s 3:30 pm and they’re tipping off for a shot at making it into the tourney.
College basketball games are a science of timing. They’ve got the minutes, the timeouts, and the guaranteed fouls down pat. College b-ball games universally last two hours in length. You can set your watch by it. Give your grandpa his pill when it starts and when it ends, because it’s going to be two hours. The NCAA counts on this, and it almost never fails them. But what if it does? What if the game lasts more than two hours and runs into selection-show-time, only there’s no finished bracket to present?
Take for example the Baylor vs. Texas A&M game earlier this year. The crowd in College Station, Texas, thought they had an exciting one going when regulation ended with a 64-to-64 tie heading into overtime. Little did they know that it would be five overtimes before Baylor walked away with a 116-to-110 win. Now, games like this are not common at all. But extended games of two and three overtimes happen commonly every year. What if one strikes the Big 10? Suddenly it’s unranked and unexpected Iowa battling mighty Wisconsin in the third OT at 6:25 pm.
The selection committee, in this situation, has to now make two tournament brackets for CBS to air. There’s the one where everything goes as planned and Wisconsin walks away victorious. And there’s the other where Iowa does the unthinkable and earns an automatic berth into the Dance. It would seem, considering this is a TV show and graphics and scripts must be written and loaded, that a half-hour is not enough time to make such crucial judgments.
Worse yet, the pressure of such an enormous task in a short time panics the selection crew sending them all into the fetal position. Greg Gumbel must now adlib on screen at 7 pm for minutes on end as a disappointed nation waits to see where they’ll have to travel on the map to see their beloved team play. Advertisers freak.
Why is the NCAA risking this?
College basketball is a powerful and influential industry. It shapes portfolios and, more importantly, it shapes lives. All of this is excluding the hundreds of millions in cash that exchange hand-to-hand from gamblers every year.One need only look to Gonzaga University for proof. Now a tournament staple, the Zags didn’t make it to the Big Dance for the first time until 1995. After some successful runs, they charged all the way to the Elite 8 in ‘99 forever changing the landscape of that school. In one year, Gonzaga saw a 22% increase in student enrollment. That’s without mentioniong the millions it made in donations, season ticket sales, and merchandise. The Zags now play in an arena twice the size of the one the ‘99 team dribbled in. Even the school’s business and science buildings saw extensions of up to 47,000 feet added, due in part at least to the men’s team’s success.
With me personally, I had already picked out UNC-Wilmington as my school of choice in early 2002. But watching the Seahawks take down four-seed Southern Cal sure didn’t make me regret my decision.
And don’t tell me George Mason University is in worse shape than it was two years ago on this day.
Yes, the NCAA has a lot on its plate. The decisions their chosen few have to make are monumental and can define schools and lives for generations to come. With the Big Dance not beginning until a week after the brackets are announced, why still does the league insist on rushing their judgment? This risk-taking will ultimately lead to embarrassment, leaving no difference between the men’s hoop programs and the failures of the BCS. It’s not worth it.