Fantasy Breakdown Of Shipping Erik Bedard To Seattle
- Baseball, Fantasy Sports -
Erik Bedard has finally been traded. After weeks of speculation and a deal that seemed virtually in place for the last 2 weeks, the trigger has been pulled on a deal that sends Bedard to Seattle for 5 prospects.
Bedard sports a repertoire that includes a vicious mid-90’s fastball, a baby hook he uses as an out pitch, along with a serviceable slider and change-up. He has steadily improved his numbers between the 04’ and 06’ seasons, consequently going from raw talent to potential stud during that span. The 2007 season saw potency become reality, as he posted a 13-5 record, 3.15 ERA, 221 K’s, and a 1.09 WHIP, all while having to sit out September with an oblique strain.
With his move to Seattle, Bedard inherits a perennial pitcher’s park in Safeco Field. With its massive foul territory, and cavernous left center gap, Bedard’s value can only increase with the switch from the hitter’s haven that is Camden Yards. While Safeco does feature a short right field porch (321 down the line), lefties have hit a combined .226 against him over the last 3 seasons, so that shouldn’t significantly affect his numbers.
His move to the AL West will prove to be a plus for him, as he no longer has to play the Yankees and Red Sox 18 times each. Playing Anaheim, Texas (particularly at Arlington Stadium), and Oakland will not be stat-padders, however, I would prefer to take my chances with the latter (if only because of the inept Athletic offense).
The defensive unit he inherits in Seattle is only a slight improvement over the one he had in Baltimore. Ichiro Suzuki, the perennial gold glover with a howitzer for an arm, mans centerfield; while the newly-minted gold glover, Adrian Beltre, is stationed at the 3-bagger. The Mariners’ feature shortstop, Yuniesky Betancourt, who undoubtedly features more range than the aging Miguel Tejada did, as well as, Kenji Johjima behind the plate, who posted a 37.8% successful throw out rate (good for 3rd best in the AL).
The Seattle offense, like the defense, represents only the slightest of forward steps for Bedard. The Mariners had a slightly higher team avg. (.287 vs .272), OBP (.337 vs .333), SLG (.425 vs .412) OPS (.762 vs 746) and more homeruns (153 vs 142) than the Orioles in 07’. In the larger scheme of things, these minute statistical difference mean little to nothing, and fantasy owners needn’t concern themselves with them.
The fact that Bedard won’t have to rely on the shaky Baltimore bullpen anymore, translates into another big plus for him. Last year, Seattle’s bullpen posted a 3.95 ERA, which looks unhittable compared to the 5.71 ERA turned in by the Oriole pen. The Mariners also feature one of the best closers in the league in J.J. Putz, who recorded 40 saves (2nd in the A.L. behind J. Borowski with 45) while posting a 1.38 ERA and an astonishing 0.70 WHIP.
Another small tidbit to consider is that in leaving Baltimore, Bedard is also leaving the invaluable tutelage of pitching coach, Leo Mazzone. When he was in Atlanta, it was no coincidence that pitchers seemed to get better while under his guidance, and worse after they left (See: Wright, Jaret). The significance of this loss is softened because the man occupying Seattle’s pitching coach position is Mel Stottlemyre. If I had to build a team I would take Mazzone and his incessant rocking on the bench over Stottlemyre, but given the impressiveness of their resumes, I believe this becomes a moot point from a fantasy perspective.
All things considered, Bedard’s move to Seattle does boost his value, but not so significantly as to select him before the 4th round in mixed formats and 3rd round in AL only formats. He is a proven source of K’s and WHIP, but he’s never pitched 200 innings in a season (196 in 06’ is his most), and has had a history of elbow injuries. I don’t think a 15 win season is out of the question, but that could prove generous in light of an inconsistent Seattle offense. One could even make the argument that he’s not the best pitcher on his own team.
In mixed formats, he is certainly a top-10 pitcher, however, I would suggest taking him toward the back end of that 10. Pitchers like Santana, Peavy, Webb, Kazmir, Beckett, Sabathia, and Haren should be taken ahead of him (and potentially a handful of others). His value obviously increases in AL only formats, where I have him pegged as either the 4th or 5th pitcher selected (behind Kazmir, Beckett, and Sabathia; and contingent upon how you value Lackey).
Ultimately, to net Bedard on draft day is going to require you to pay top value for him. While he may very well prove to be the ace that Seattle thinks he is, be wary of over valuing him simply because of the scenery change (by overvaluing I mean, do no pass up some of the previously mentioned names to take him). The track record, while progressive and promising, is not complete enough to warrant making Bedard the centerpiece of your staff if better options exist. Anyone who does so risks hitching his pitching hopes to the star of potential; and potential, as any fantasy owner should know, is ever intriguing but never dependable as gauge for fantasy production.
Derek is a special contributor to MindRiteSports.com. He can be reached at ddaskala@gmu.edu.
This baseball off-season has been dominated by two stories of dissimilar natures. One is the much maligned
Santana’s move from the Metrodome to the confines of Shea will only matter marginally. The Metrodome ranked as the 3rd most favorable park for pitchers in 2007, while Shea ranked only 

Shoulder-to-shoulder, among the jersey-wearers and beer-toting folk watching the large LCD TV, sat a man decked out in his own jersey (Patriots) and on the table in place of buffalo wings sat his laptop. A computer nerd among sports junkies in a bar? I was completely baffled.
Fantasy sports is changing the way we view our favorite games. And not just because nerds and jocks can be friends now, although that is baffling all in itself.
It’s all a game though, isn’t it? Try wearing a Cowboys jersey in FedEx Stadium and let me know if you agree. But that same Cowboys fan could mosey on into the right bar full of fantasy sports fans and offer his computer to checking scores of fantasy games and they may even be embraced.